#triton submersible | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

xtruss · 2 years ago

Text

The Titan Submersible Was “An Accident Waiting to Happen”

Interviews and e-mails with expedition leaders and employees reveal how OceanGate ignored desperate warnings from inside and outside the company. “It’s a lemon,” one wrote.

— By Ben Taub | July 1, 2023

Stockton Rush, the co-founder and C.E.O. of OceanGate, inside Cyclops I, a submersible, on July 19, 2017. Photographs by Balazs Gardi

The primary task of a submersible is to not implode. The second is to reach the surface, even if the pilot is unconscious, with oxygen to spare. The third is for the occupants to be able to open the hatch once they surface. The fourth is for the submersible to be easy to find, through redundant tracking and communications systems, in case rescue is required. Only the fifth task is what is ordinarily thought of as the primary one: to transport people into the dark, hostile deep.

At dawn four summers ago, the French submariner and Titanic expert Paul-Henri Nargeolet stood on the bow of an expedition vessel in the North Atlantic. The air was cool and thick with fog, the sea placid, the engine switched off, and the Titanic was some thirty-eight hundred metres below. The crew had gathered for a solemn ceremony, to pay tribute to the more than fifteen hundred people who had died in the most famous maritime disaster more than a hundred years ago. Rob McCallum, the expedition leader, gave a short speech, then handed a wreath to Nargeolet, the oldest man on the ship. As is tradition, the youngest—McCallum’s nephew—was summoned to place his hand on the wreath, and he and Nargeolet let it fall into the sea.

Inside a hangar on the ship’s stern sat a submersible known as the Limiting Factor. In the previous year, McCallum, Nargeolet, and others had taken it around the Earth, as part of the Five Deeps Expedition, a journey to the deepest point in each ocean. The team had mapped unexplored trenches and collected scientific samples, and the Limiting Factor’s chief pilot, Victor Vescovo—a Texan hedge-fund manager who had financed the entire operation—had set numerous diving records. But, to another member of the expedition team, Patrick Lahey, the C.E.O. of Triton Submarines (which had designed and built the submersible), one record meant more than the rest: the marine-classification society DNV had certified the Limiting Factor’s “maximum permissible diving depth” as “unlimited.” That process was far from theoretical; a DNV inspection engineer was involved in every stage of the submersible’s creation, from design to sea trials and diving. He even sat in the passenger seat as Lahey piloted the Limiting Factor to the deepest point on Earth.

After the wreath sank from view, Vescovo climbed down the submersible hatch, and the dive began. For some members of the crew, the site of the wreck was familiar. McCallum, who co-founded a company called eyos Expeditions, had transported tourists to the Titanic in the two-thousands, using two Soviet submarines that had been rated to six thousand metres. Another crew member was a Titanic obsessive—his endless talk of davits and well decks still rattles in my head. But it was Paul-Henri Nargeolet whose life was most entwined with the Titanic. He had dived it more than thirty times, beginning shortly after its discovery, in 1985, and now served as the underwater-research director for the organization that owns salvaging rights to the wreck.

Nargeolet had also spent the past year as Vescovo’s safety manager. “When I set out on the Five Deeps project, I told Patrick Lahey, ‘Look, I don’t know submarine technology—I need someone who works for me to independently validate whatever design you come up with, and its construction and operation,’ ” Vescovo recalled, this week. “He recommended P. H. Nargeolet, whom he had known for decades.” Nargeolet, whose wife had recently died, was a former French naval commander—an underwater-explosives expert who had spent much of his life at sea. “He had a sterling reputation, the perfect résumé,” Vescovo said. “And he was French. And I love the French.”

When Vescovo reached the silty bottom at the Titanic site, he recalled his private preparations with Nargeolet. “He had very good knowledge of the currents and the wreck,” Vescovo told me. “He briefed me on very specific tactical things: ‘Stay away from this place on the stern’; ‘Don’t go here’; ‘Try and maintain this distance at this part of the wreck.’ ” Vescovo surfaced about seven hours later, exhausted and rattled from the debris that he had encountered at the ship’s ruins, which risk entangling submersibles that approach too close. But the Limiting Factor was completely fine. According to its certification from DNV, a “deep dive,” for insurance and inspection purposes, was anything below four thousand metres. A journey to the Titanic, thirty-eight hundred metres down, didn’t even count.

Nargeolet remained obsessed with the Titanic, and, before long, he was invited to return. “To P. H., the Titanic was Ulysses’ sirens—he could not resist it,” Vescovo told me. A couple of weeks ago, Nargeolet climbed into a radically different submersible, owned by a company called OceanGate, which had spent years marketing to the general public that, for a fee of two hundred and fifty thousand dollars, it would bring people to the most famous shipwreck on Earth. “People are so enthralled with Titanic,” OceanGate’s founder, Stockton Rush, told a BBC documentary crew last year. “I read an article that said there are three words in the English language that are known throughout the planet. And that’s ‘Coca-Cola,’ ‘God,’ and ‘Titanic.’ ”

Nargeolet served as a guide to the wreck, Rush as the pilot. The other three occupants were tourists, including a father and son. But, before they reached the bottom, the submersible vanished, triggering an international search-and-rescue operation, with an accompanying media frenzy centered on counting down the hours until oxygen would run out.

McCallum, who was leading an expedition in Papua New Guinea at the time, knew the outcome almost instantly. “The report that I got immediately after the event—long before they were overdue—was that the sub was approaching thirty-five hundred metres,” he told me, while the oxygen clock was still ticking. “It dropped weights”—meaning that the team had aborted the dive—“then it lost comms, and lost tracking, and an implosion was heard.”

An investigation by the U.S. Coast Guard is ongoing; some debris from the wreckage has been salvaged, but the implosion was so violent and comprehensive that the precise cause of the disaster may never be known.

Until June 18th, a manned deep-ocean submersible had never imploded. But, to McCallum, Lahey, and other experts, the OceanGate disaster did not come as a surprise—they had been warning of the submersible’s design flaws for more than five years, filing complaints to the U.S. government and to OceanGate itself, and pleading with Rush to abandon his aspirations. As they mourned Nargeolet and the other passengers, they decided to reveal OceanGate’s history of knowingly shoddy design and construction. “You can’t cut corners in the deep,” McCallum had told Rush. “It’s not about being a disruptor. It’s about the laws of physics.”

The submersible Antipodes at the OceanGate headquarters, in Everett, Washington, on July 19, 2017.

Stockton Rush was named for two of his ancestors who signed the Declaration of Independence: Richard Stockton and Benjamin Rush. His maternal grandfather was an oil-and-shipping tycoon. As a teen-ager, Rush became an accomplished commercial jet pilot, and he studied aerospace engineering at Princeton, where he graduated in 1984.

Rush wanted to become a fighter pilot. But his eyesight wasn’t perfect, and so he went to business school instead. Years later, he expressed a desire to travel to space, and he reportedly dreamed of becoming the first human to set foot on Mars. In 2004, Rush travelled to the Mojave Desert, where he watched the launch of the first privately funded aircraft to brush against the edge of space. The only occupant was the test pilot; nevertheless, as Rush used to tell it, Richard Branson stood on the wing and announced that a new era of space tourism had arrived. At that point, Rush “abruptly lost interest,” according to a profile in Smithsonian magazine. “I didn’t want to go up into space as a tourist,” he said. “I wanted to be Captain Kirk on the Enterprise. I wanted to explore.”

Rush had grown up scuba diving in Tahiti, the Cayman Islands, and the Red Sea. In his mid-forties, he tinkered with a kit for a single-person mini-submersible, and piloted it around at shallow depths near Seattle, where he lived. A few years later, in 2009, he co-founded OceanGate, with a dream to bring tourists to the ocean world. “I had come across this business anomaly I couldn’t explain,” he recalled. “If three-quarters of the planet is water, how come you can’t access it?”

OceanGate’s first submersible wasn’t made by the company itself; it was built in 1973, and Lahey later piloted it in the North Sea, while working in the oil-and-gas industry. In the nineties, he helped refit it into a tourist submersible, and in 2009, after it had been sold a few times, and renamed Antipodes, OceanGate bought it. “I didn’t have any direct interaction with them at the time,” Lahey recalled. “Stockton was one of these people that was buying these older subs and trying to repurpose them.”

In 2015, OceanGate announced that it had built its first submersible, in collaboration with the University of Washington’s Applied Physics Laboratory. In fact, it was mostly a cosmetic and electrical refit; Lahey and his partners had built the underlying vessel, called Lula, for a Portuguese marine research nonprofit almost two decades before. It had a pressure hull that was the shape of a capsule pill and made of steel, with a large acrylic viewport on one end. It was designed to go no deeper than five hundred metres—a comfortable cruising depth for military submarines. OceanGate now called it Cyclops I.

Most submersibles have duplicate control systems, running on separate batteries—that way, if one system fails, the other still works. But, during the refit, engineers at the University of Washington rigged the Cyclops I to run from a single PlayStation 3 controller. “Stockton is very interested in being able to quickly train pilots,” Dave Dyer, a principal engineer, said, in a video published by his laboratory. Another engineer referred to it as “a combination steering wheel and gas pedal.”

Around that time, Rush set his sights on the Titanic. OceanGate would have to design a new submersible. But Rush decided to keep most of the design elements of Cyclops I. Suddenly, the University of Washington was no longer involved in the project, although OceanGate’s contract with the Applied Physics Laboratory was less than one-fifth complete; it is unclear what Dyer, who did not respond to an interview request, thought of Rush’s plan to essentially reconstruct a craft that was designed for five hundred metres of pressure to withstand eight times that much. As the company planned Cyclops II, Rush reached out to McCallum for help.

“He wanted me to run his Titanic operation for him,” McCallum recalled. “At the time, I was the only person he knew who had run commercial expedition trips to Titanic. Stockton’s plan was to go a step further and build a vehicle specifically for this multi-passenger expedition.” McCallum gave him some advice on marketing and logistics, and eventually visited the workshop, outside Seattle, where he examined the Cyclops I. He was disturbed by what he saw. “Everyone was drinking Kool-Aid and saying how cool they were with a Sony PlayStation,” he told me. “And I said at the time, ‘Does Sony know that it’s been used for this application? Because, you know, this is not what it was designed for.’ And now you have the hand controller talking to a Wi-Fi unit, which is talking to a black box, which is talking to the sub’s thrusters. There were multiple points of failure.” The system ran on Bluetooth, according to Rush. But, McCallum continued, “every sub in the world has hardwired controls for a reason—that if the signal drops out, you’re not fucked.”

One day, McCallum climbed into the Cyclops for a test dive at a marina. There, he met the chief pilot, David Lochridge, a Scotsman who had spent three decades as a submersible pilot and an engineer—first in the Royal Navy, then as a private contractor. Lochridge had worked all over the world: on offshore wind farms in the North Sea; on subsea-cables installations in the Atlantic, Indian, and Pacific oceans; on manned submarine trials with the Swedish Navy; on submarine-rescue operations for the navies of Britain and Singapore. But, during the harbor trial, the Cyclops got stuck in shallow water. “It was hilarious, because there were four very experienced operators in the sub, stuck at twenty or twenty-five feet, and we had to sit there for a few hours while they worked it out,” McCallum recalled. He liked and trusted Lochridge. But, of the sub, he said, “This thing is a mutt.”

Rush eventually decided that he would not attempt to have the Titanic-bound vehicle classed by a marine-certification agency such as DNV. He had no interest in welcoming into the project an external evaluator who would, as he saw it, “need to first be educated before being qualified to ‘validate’ any innovations.”

That marked the end of McCallum’s desire to be associated with the project. “The minute that I found out that he was not going to class the vehicle, that’s when I said, ‘I’m sorry, I just can’t be involved,’ ” he told me. “I couldn’t tell him anything about the Five Deeps project at that time. But I was able to say, ‘Look, I am involved with other projects that are building classed subs’—of course, I was talking about the Limiting Factor—‘and I can tell you that the class society has been nothing but supportive. They are actually part of our innovation process. We’re using the brainpower of their engineers to feed into our design.

“Stockton didn’t like that,” McCallum continued. “He didn’t like to be told that he was on the fringe.” As word got out that Rush planned to take tourists to the Titanic, McCallum recalled, “people would ring me, and say, ‘We’ve always wanted to go to Titanic. What do you think?’ And I would tell them, ‘Never get in an unclassed sub. I wouldn’t do it, and you shouldn’t, either.’ ”

In early 2018, McCallum heard that Lochridge had left OceanGate. “I’d be keen to pick your brain if you have a few moments,” McCallum e-mailed him. “I’m keen to get a handle on exactly how bad things are. I do get reports, but I don’t know if they are accurate.” Whatever his differences with Rush, McCallum wanted the venture to succeed; the submersible industry is small, and a single disaster could destroy it. But the only way forward without a catastrophic operational failure—which he had been told was “certain,” he wrote—was for OceanGate to redesign the submersible in coördination with a classification society. “Stockton must be gutted,” McCallum told Lochridge, of his departure. “You were the star player . . . . . and the only one that gave me a hint of confidence.”

“I think you are going to [be] even more taken aback when I tell you what’s happening,” Lochridge replied. He added that he was afraid of retaliation from Rush—“We both know he has influence and money”—but would share his assessment with McCallum, in private: “That sub is Not safe to dive.”

“Do you think the sub could be made safe to dive, or is it a complete lemon?” McCallum replied. “You will get a lot of support from people in the industry . . . . everyone is watching and waiting and quietly shitting their pants.”

“It’s a lemon.”

“Oh dear,” McCallum replied. “Oh dear, oh dear.”

David Lochridge, OceanGate’s former director of marine operations, pilots Cyclops I during a test dive in Everett, on July 19, 2017.

Lochridge had been hired by OceanGate in May, 2015, as its director of marine operations and chief submersible pilot. The company moved him and his family to Washington, and helped him apply for a green card. But, before long, he was clashing with Rush and Tony Nissen, the company’s director of engineering, on matters of design and safety.

Every aspect of submersible design and construction is a trade-off between strength and weight. In order for the craft to remain suspended underwater, without rising or falling, the buoyancy of each component must be offset against the others. Most deep-ocean submersibles use spherical titanium hulls and are counterbalanced in water by syntactic foam, a buoyant material made up of millions of hollow glass balls, which is attached to the external frame. But this adds bulk to the submersible. And the weight of titanium limits the practical size of the pressure hull, so that it can accommodate no more than two or three people. Spheres are “the best geometry for pressure, but not for occupation,” as Rush put it.

The Cyclops II needed to fit as many passengers as possible. “You don’t do the coolest thing you’re ever going to do in your life by yourself,” Rush told an audience at the GeekWire Summit last fall. “You take your wife, your son, your daughter, your best friend. You’ve got to have four people” besides the pilot. Rush planned to have room for a Titanic guide and three passengers. The Cyclops II could fit that many occupants only if it had a cylindrical midsection. But the size dictated the choice of materials. The steel hull of Cyclops I was too thin for Titanic depths—but a thicker steel hull would add too much weight. In December, 2016, OceanGate announced that it had started construction on Cyclops II, and that its cylindrical midsection would be made of carbon fibre. The idea, Rush explained in interviews, was that carbon fibre was a strong material that was significantly lighter than traditional metals. “Carbon fibre is three times better than titanium on strength-to-buoyancy,” he said.

A month later, OceanGate hired a company called Spencer Composites to build the carbon-fibre hull. “They basically said, ‘This is the pressure we have to meet, this is the factor of safety, this is the basic envelope. Go design and build it,’ ” the founder, Brian Spencer, told CompositesWorld, in the spring of 2017. He was given a deadline of six weeks.

Toward the end of that year, Lochridge became increasingly concerned. OceanGate would soon begin manned sea trials for Cyclops II in the Bahamas, and he believed that there was a chance that they would result in catastrophe. The consequences for Lochridge could extend beyond OceanGate’s business and the trauma of losing colleagues; as director of marine operations, Lochridge had a contract specifying that he was ultimately responsible for “ensuring the safety of all crew and clients.”

On the workshop floor, he raised questions about potential flaws in the design and build processes. But his concerns were dismissed. OceanGate’s position was that such matters were outside the scope of his responsibilities; he was “not hired to provide engineering services, or to design or develop Cyclops II,” the company later said, in a court filing. Nevertheless, before the handover of the submersible to the operations team, Rush directed Lochridge to carry out an inspection, because his job description also required him to sign off on the submersible’s readiness for deployment.

On January 18, 2018, Lochridge studied each major component, and found several critical aspects to be defective or unproven. He drafted a detailed report, which has not previously been made public, and attached photographs of the elements of greatest concern. Glue was coming away from the seams of ballast bags, and mounting bolts threatened to rupture them; both sealing faces had errant plunge holes and O-ring grooves that deviated from standard design parameters. The exostructure and electrical pods used different metals, which could result in galvanic corrosion when exposed to seawater. The thruster cables posed “snagging hazards”; the iridium satellite beacon, to transmit the submersible’s position after surfacing, was attached with zip ties. The flooring was highly flammable; the interior vinyl wrapping emitted “highly toxic gasses upon ignition.”

To assess the carbon-fibre hull, Lochridge examined a small cross-section of material. He found that it had “very visible signs of delamination and porosity”—it seemed possible that, after repeated dives, it would come apart. He shone a light at the sample from behind, and photographed beams streaming through splits in the midsection in a disturbing, irregular pattern. The only safe way to dive, Lochridge concluded, was to first carry out a full scan of the hull.

The next day, Lochridge sent his report to Rush, Nissen, and other members of the OceanGate leadership. “Verbal communication of the key items I have addressed in my attached document have been dismissed on several occasions, so I feel now I must make this report so there is an official record in place,” he wrote. “Until suitable corrective actions are in place and closed out, Cyclops 2 (Titan) should not be manned during any of the upcoming trials.”

Rush was furious; he called a meeting that afternoon, and recorded it on his phone. For the next two hours, the OceanGate leadership insisted that no hull testing was necessary—an acoustic monitoring system, to detect fraying fibres, would serve in its place. According to the company, the system would alert the pilot to the possibility of catastrophic failure “with enough time to arrest the descent and safely return to surface.” But, in a court filing, Lochridge’s lawyer wrote, “this type of acoustic analysis would only show when a component is about to fail—often milliseconds before an implosion—and would not detect any existing flaws prior to putting pressure onto the hull.” A former senior employee who was present at the meeting told me, “We didn’t even have a baseline. We didn’t know what it would sound like if something went wrong.”

OceanGate’s lawyer wrote, “The parties found themselves at an impasse—Mr. Lochridge was not, and specifically stated that he could not be made comfortable with OceanGate’s testing protocol, while Mr. Rush was unwilling to change the company’s plans.” The meeting ended in Lochridge’s firing.

Soon afterward, Rush asked OceanGate’s director of finance and administration whether she’d like to take over as chief submersible pilot. “It freaked me out that he would want me to be head pilot, since my background is in accounting,” she told me. She added that several of the engineers were in their late teens and early twenties, and were at one point being paid fifteen dollars an hour. Without Lochridge around, “I could not work for Stockton,” she said. “I did not trust him.” As soon as she was able to line up a new job, she quit.

“I would consider myself pretty ballsy when it comes to doing things that are dangerous, but that sub is an accident waiting to happen,” Lochridge wrote to McCallum, two weeks later. “There’s no way on earth you could have paid me to dive the thing.” Of Rush, he added, “I don’t want to be seen as a Tattle tale but I’m so worried he kills himself and others in the quest to boost his ego.”

McCallum forwarded the exchange to Patrick Lahey, the C.E.O. of Triton Submarines, whose response was emphatic: if Lochridge “genuinely believes this submersible poses a threat to the occupants,” then he had a moral obligation to inform the authorities. “To remain quiet makes him complicit,” Lahey wrote. “I know that may sound ominous but it is true. History is full of horrific examples of accidents and tragedies that were a direct result of people’s silence.”

OceanGate claimed that Cyclops II had “the first pressure vessel of its kind in the world.” But there’s a reason that Triton and other manufacturers don’t use carbon fibre in their hulls. Under compression, “it’s a capricious fucking material, which is the last fucking thing you want to associate with a pressure boundary,” Lahey told me.

“With titanium, there’s a purpose to a pressure test that goes beyond just seeing whether it will survive,” John Ramsay, the designer of the Limiting Factor, explained. The metal gradually strengthens under repeated exposure to incredible stresses. With carbon fibre, however, pressure testing slowly breaks the hull, fibre by tiny fibre. “If you’re repeatedly nearing the threshold of the material, then there’s just no way of knowing how many cycles it will survive,” he said.

“It doesn’t get more sensational than dead people in a sub on the way to Titanic,” Lahey’s business partner, the co-founder of Triton Submarines, wrote to his team, on March 1, 2018. McCallum tried to reason with Rush directly. “You are wanting to use a prototype un-classed technology in a very hostile place,” he e-mailed. “As much as I appreciate entrepreneurship and innovation, you are potentially putting an entire industry at risk.”

Rush replied four days later, saying that he had “grown tired of industry players who try to use a safety argument to stop innovation and new entrants from entering their small existing market.” He understood that his approach “flies in the face of the submersible orthodoxy, but that is the nature of innovation,” he wrote. “We have heard the baseless cries of ‘you are going to kill someone’ way too often. I take this as a serious personal insult.”

In response, McCallum listed a number of specific concerns, from his “humble perch” as an expedition leader. “In your race to Titanic you are mirroring that famous catch cry ‘she is unsinkable,’ ” McCallum wrote. The correspondence ended soon afterward; Rush asked McCallum to work for him—then threatened him with a lawsuit, in an effort to silence him, when he declined.

By now, McCallum had introduced Lochridge to Lahey. Lahey wrote him, “If Ocean Gate is unwilling to consider or investigate your concerns with you directly perhaps some other means of getting them to pay attention is required.”

Lochridge replied that he had already contacted the United States Department of Labor, alleging to its Occupational Safety and Health Administration that he had been terminated in retaliation for raising safety concerns. He also sent the osha investigator Paul McDevitt a copy of his Cyclops II inspection report, hoping that the government might take actions that would “prevent the potential for harm to life.”

A few weeks later, McDevitt contacted OceanGate, noting that he was looking into Lochridge’s firing as a whistle-blower-protection matter. OceanGate’s lawyer Thomas Gilman soon issued Lochridge a court summons: he had ten days to withdraw his osha claim and pay OceanGate almost ten thousand dollars in legal expenses. Otherwise, Gilman wrote, OceanGate would sue him, take measures to destroy his professional reputation, and accuse him of immigration fraud. Gilman also reported to osha that Lochridge had orchestrated his own firing because he “wanted to leave his job and maintain his ability to collect unemployment benefits.” (McDevitt, of osha, notified the Coast Guard of Lochridge’s complaint. There is no evidence that the Coast Guard ever followed up.)

Lochridge received the summons while he was at his father’s funeral. He and his wife hired a lawyer, but it quickly became clear that “he didn’t have the money to fight this guy,” Lahey told me. (Lochridge declined to be interviewed.) Lahey covered the rest of the expenses, but, after more than half a year of legal wrangling, and threats of deportation, Lochridge withdrew his whistle-blower claim with osha so that he could go on with his life. Lahey was crestfallen. “He didn’t consult me about that decision,” Lahey recalled. “It’s not that he had to—it was his fight, not mine. But I was underwriting the cost of it, because I believed in the idea that this inspection report, which he wouldn’t share with anybody, needed to see the light of day.”

Stockton Rush in front of Cyclops I, on July 19, 2017.

A few weeks after Lochridge was fired, OceanGate announced that it was testing its new submersible in the marina of Everett, Washington, and would soon begin shallow-water trials in Puget Sound. To preëmpt any concerns about the carbon-fibre hull, the company touted the acoustic monitoring system, which was later patented in Rush’s name. “Safety is our number one priority,” Rush said, in an OceanGate press release. “We believe real-time health monitoring should be standard safety equipment on all manned-submersibles.”

“He’s spinning the fact that his sub requires a hull warning system into something positive,” Jarl Stromer, Triton’s regulatory and class-compliance manager, reported to Lahey. “He’s making it sound like the Cyclops is more advanced because it has this system when the opposite is true: The submersible is so experimental, and the factor of safety completely unknown, that it requires a system to warn the pilot of impending collapse.”

Like Lochridge, Triton’s outside counsel, Brad Patrick, considered the risk to life to be so evident that the government should get involved. He drafted a letter to McDevitt, the osha investigator, urging the Department of Labor to take “immediate and decisive action to stop OceanGate” from taking passengers to the Titanic “before people die. It is that simple.” He went on, “At the bottom of all of this is the inevitable tension betwixt greed and safety.”

But Patrick’s letter was never sent. Other people at Triton worried that the Department of Labor might perceive the letter as an attack on a business rival. By now, OceanGate had renamed Cyclops II “Titan,” apparently to honor the Titanic. “I cannot tell you how much I fucking hated it when he changed the goddam name to Titan,” Lahey told me. “That was uncomfortably close to our name.”

“Stockton strategically structured everything to be out of U.S. jurisdiction” for its Titanic pursuits, the former senior OceanGate employee told me. “It was deliberate.” In a legal filing, the company reported that the submersible was “being developed and assembled in Washington, but will be owned by a Bahamian entity, will be registered in the Bahamas and will operate exclusively outside the territorial waters of the United States.” Although it is illegal to transport passengers in an unclassed, experimental submersible, “under U.S. regulations, you can kill crew,” McCallum told me. “You do get in a little bit of trouble, in the eyes of the law. But, if you kill a passenger, you’re in big trouble. And so everyone was classified as a ‘mission specialist.’ There were no passengers—the word ‘passenger’ was never used.” No one bought tickets; they contributed an amount of money set by Rush to one of OceanGate’s entities, to fund their own missions.

“It is truly hard to imagine the discernment it took for Stockton to string together each of the links in the chain,” Patrick noted. “ ‘How do I avoid liability in Washington State? How do I avoid liability with an offshore corporate structure? How do I keep the U.S. Coast Guard from breathing down my neck?’ ”

But OceanGate had a retired Coast Guard rear admiral, John Lockwood, on its board of directors. “His experiences at the highest levels of the Coast Guard and in international maritime affairs will allow OceanGate to refine our client offerings,” Rush announced with his appointment, in 2013. Lockwood said that he hoped “to help bring operational and regulatory expertise” to OceanGate’s affairs. (Lockwood did not respond to a request for comment.) Still, Rush failed to win over the submersible industry. When he asked Don Walsh, a renowned oceanographer who reached the deepest point in the ocean, in 1960, to consult on the Titanic venture, Walsh replied, “I am concerned that my affiliation with your program at this late date would appear to be nothing more than an endorsement of what you are already doing.”

That spring, more than three dozen industry experts sent a letter to OceanGate, expressing their “unanimous concern” about its upcoming Titanic expedition—for which it had already sold places. Among the signers were Lahey, McCallum, Walsh, and a Coast Guard senior inspector. “OceanGate’s anticipated dive schedule in the spring of 2018 meant that they were going to take people down, and we had a great deal of concern about them surviving that trip,” Patrick told me. But sea trials were a disaster, owing to problems with the launch-and-recovery system, and OceanGate scuttled its Titanic operations for that year. Lochridge broke the news to Lahey. “Lives have been saved for a short while anyway,” he wrote.

OceanGate kept selling tickets, but did not dive to the Titanic for the next three years. It appears that the company spent this period testing materials, and that it built several iterations of the carbon-fibre hull. But it is difficult to know what tests were done, exactly, and how many hulls were made, and by whom, because Rush’s public statements are deeply unreliable. He claimed at various points to have design and testing partnerships with Boeing and nasa, and that at least one iteration of the hull would be built at the Marshall Space Flight Center, in Huntsville, Alabama. But none of those things were true. Meanwhile, soon after Lochridge’s departure, a college newspaper quoted a recent graduate as saying that he and his classmates had started working on the Titan’s electrical systems as interns, while they were still in school. “The whole electrical system,” he said. “That was our design, we implemented it, and it works.”

By the time that OceanGate finally began diving to the Titanic, in 2021, it had refined its pitch to its “mission specialists.” The days of insinuating that Titan was safe had ended. Now Rush portrayed the submersible as existing at the very fringe of what was physically possible. Clients signed waivers and were informed that the submersible was experimental and unclassed. But the framing was that this was how pioneering exploration is done.

“We were all told—intimately informed—that this was a dangerous mission that could result in death,” an OceanGate “mission specialist” told Fox News last week. “We were versed in how the sub operated. We were versed in various protocols. But there’s a limit . . . it’s not a safe operation, inherently. And that’s part of research and development and exploration.” He went on, “If the Wright brothers had crashed on their first flight, they would have still left the bonds of Earth.” Another “mission specialist” wrote in a blog post that, a month before the implosion, Rush had confessed that he’d “gotten the carbon fiber used to make the Titan at a big discount from Boeing because it was past its shelf-life for use in airplanes.”

“Carbon fibre makes noise,” Rush told David Pogue, a CBS News correspondent, last summer, during one of the Titanic expeditions. “It crackles. The first time you pressurize it, if you think about it—of those million fibres, a couple of ’em are sorta weak. They shouldn’t have made the team.” He spoke of signs of hull breakage as if it were perfectly routine. “The first time we took it to full pressure, it made a bunch of noise. The second time, it made very little noise.”

Fibres do not regenerate between dives. Nevertheless, Rush seemed unconcerned. “It’s a huge amount of pressure from the point where we’d say, ‘Oh, the hull’s not happy,’ to when it implodes,” he noted. “You just have to stop your descent.”

It’s not clear that Rush could always stop his descent. Once, as he piloted passengers to the wreck, a malfunction prevented Rush from dropping weights. Passengers calmly discussed sleeping on the bottom of the ocean, thirty-eight hundred metres down; after twenty-four hours, a drop-weight mechanism would dissolve in the seawater, allowing the submersible to surface. Eventually, Rush managed to release the weights manually, using a hydraulic pump. “This is why you want your pilot to be an engineer,” a passenger said, smiling, as another “mission specialist” filmed her.

Last year, a BBC documentary crew joined the expedition. Rush stayed on the surface vessel while Scott Griffith, OceanGate’s director of logistics and quality assurance, piloted a scientist and three other passengers down. (Griffith did not respond to a request for comment.) During the launch, a diver in the water noticed and reported to the surface vessel that something with a thruster seemed off. Nevertheless, the mission continued.

More than two hours passed; after Titan touched down in the silt, Griffith fired the thrusters and realized something was wrong.“I don’t know what’s going on,” he said. As he fiddled with the PlayStation controller, a passenger looked out the viewport.

“Am I spinning?” Griffith asked.

“Yes.”

“I am?”

“Looks like it,” another passenger said.

“Oh, my God,” Griffith muttered. One of the thrusters had been installed in the wrong direction. “The only thing I can do is a three-sixty,” he said.

They were in the debris field, three hundred metres from the intact part of the wreck. One of the clients said that she had delayed buying a car, getting married, and having kids, all “because I wanted to go to Titanic,” but they couldn’t make their way over to its bow. Griffith relayed the situation to the ship. Rush’s solution was to “remap the PS3 controller.”

Rush couldn’t remember where the buttons were, and it seems as though there was no spare controller on the ship. Someone loaded an image of a PlayStation 3 controller from the Internet, and Rush worked out a new button routine. “Yeah—left and right might be forward and back. Huh. I don’t know,” he said. “It might work.”

“Right is forward,” Griffith read off his screen, two and a half miles below. “Uh—I’m going to have to write this down.”

“Right is forward,” Rush said. “Great! Live with it.”

Shipwrecks are notoriously difficult and dangerous to dive. Rusted cables drape the Titanic, moving with the currents; a broken crow’s nest dangles over the deck. Griffith piloted the submersible over to the wreck, and passengers within feet of it, while teaching himself in real time to operate a Bluetooth controller whose buttons suddenly had different functions than those for which he had trained.

Various models of Cyclops II are exhibited alongside a model of the Titanic, at the OceanGate headquarters, on July 19, 2017.

“If you’re not breaking things, you’re not innovating,” Rush said, at the GeekWire Summit last fall. “If you’re operating within a known environment, as most submersible manufacturers do—they don’t break things. To me, the more stuff you’ve broken, the more innovative you’ve been.”

The Titan’s viewport was made of acrylic and seven inches thick. “That’s another thing where I broke the rules,” Rush said to Pogue, the CBS News journalist. He went on to refer to a “very well-known” acrylic expert, Jerry D. Stachiw, who wrote an eleven-hundred-page manual called “Handbook of Acrylics for Submersibles, Hyperbaric Chambers, and Aquaria.” “It has safety factors that—they were so high, he didn’t call ’em safety factors. He called ’em conversion factors,” Rush said. “According to the rules,” he added, his viewport was “not allowed.”

It seemed as if Rush believed that acrylic’s transparent quality would give him ample warning before failure. “You can see every surface,” he said. “And if you’ve overstressed it, or you’ve even come close, it starts to get this crazing effect.”

“And if that happened underwater . . .”

“You just stop and go to the surface.”

“You would have time to get back up?” Pogue asked.

“Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. It’s way more warning than you need.”

John Ramsay, who has designed several acrylic-hulled submersibles, was less sure. “You’ll probably never be able to find out the source of failure” of the Titan, he told me, in a recent phone call from his cottage in southwest England. But it seems as though Rush did not understand how acrylic limits are calculated. “Where Stockton is talking about those things called conversion factors . . .”

Ramsay grabbed a copy of Stachiw’s acrylic handbook from his spare bedroom. When Stachiw’s team was doing its tests, “they would pressurize it really fast, the acrylic would implode, and then they would assign a conversion factor, to tabulate a safe diving depth,” he explained. “So let’s say the sample imploded at twelve hundred metres. You apply a conversion factor of six, and you get a rating of two hundred metres.” He paused, and spoke slowly, to make sure I understood the gravity of what followed. “It’s specifically not called a safety factor, because the acrylic is not safe to twelve hundred metres,” he said. “I’ve got a massive report on all of this, because we’ve just had to reverse engineer all of Jerry Statchiw’s work to determine when our own acrylic will fail.” The risk zone begins at about twice the depth rating.

According to David Lochridge’s court filings, from 2018, Cyclops II’s viewport had a depth rating of only thirteen hundred metres, approximately one-third of Titanic’s depth. It is possible that this had changed by the time passengers finally dived. But, Lochridge’s lawyer wrote, OceanGate “refused to pay for the manufacturer to build a viewport that would meet the required depth.”

In May, Rush invited Victor Vescovo to join his Titanic expedition. “I turned him down,” Vescovo told me. “I didn’t even want the appearance that I was sanctioning his operation.” But his friend—the British billionaire Hamish Harding, whom Vescovo had previously taken in the Limiting Factor to the bottom of the Mariana Trench—signed up to be a “mission specialist.”

On the morning of June 18th, Rush climbed inside the Titan, along with Harding, the British Pakistani businessman Shahzada Dawood, and his nineteen-year-old son, Suleman, who had reportedly told a relative that he was terrified of diving in a submersible but would do so anyway, because it was Father’s Day. He carried with him a Rubik’s Cube so that he could solve it in front of the Titanic wreck. The fifth diver was P. H. Nargeolet, the Titanic expert—Vescovo’s former safety adviser, Lahey and McCallum’s old shipmate and friend. He had been working with OceanGate for at least a year as a wreck navigator, historian, and guide.

The force of the implosion would have been so violent that everyone on board would have died before the water touched their bodies.

For the Five Deeps crew, Nargeolet’s legacy is complicated by the circumstances of his final dives. “I had a conversation with P. H. just as recently as a few months ago,” Lahey told me. “I kept giving him shit for going out there. I said, ‘P. H., by you being out there, you legitimize what this guy’s doing. It’s a tacit endorsement. And, worse than that, I think he’s using your involvement with the project, and your presence on the site, as a way to fucking lure people into it.’ ”

Nargeolet replied that he was getting old. He was a grieving widower, and, as he told people several times in recent years, “if you have to go, that would be a good way. Instant.”

“I said, ‘O.K., so you’re ready to fucking die? Is that what it is, P. H.?’ ” Lahey recalled. “And he said, ‘No, no, but I figure that, maybe if I’m out there, I can help them avoid a tragedy.’ But instead he found himself right in the fucking center of a tragedy. And he didn’t deserve to go that way.”

“I loved P. H. Nargeolet,” Lahey continued. He started choking up. “He was a brilliant human being and somebody that I had the privilege of knowing for almost twenty-five years, and I think it’s a tremendously sad way for him to have ended his life.”

Lahey dived the Titanic in the Limiting Factor during the Five Deeps expedition, back in 2019. I remember him climbing out of the submersible and being upset at the fact that we were even there. “It’s a mess down there,” he recalled, this week. “It’s a tragic fucking place. And in some ways, you know, people paying all that money to go and fly around in a fucking graveyard . . .” He trailed off. But the loss of so much life, in 1912, set in motion new regulations and improvements for safety at sea. “And so I guess, on a positive note, you can look at that as having been a difficult and tragic lesson that probably has since saved hundreds of thousands of lives,” he said.

OceanGate declined to comment. But, in 2021, Stockton Rush told an interviewer that he would “like to be remembered as an innovator. I think it was General MacArthur who said, ‘You’re remembered for the rules you break.’ And I’ve broken some rules to make this.” He was sitting in the Titan’s hull, docked in the Port of St. John’s, the nearest port to the site where he eventually died. “The carbon fibre and titanium? There’s a rule you don’t do that. Well, I did.” ♦

— Ben Taub, A Staﬀ Writer, is the recipient of the 2020 Pulitzer Prize for feature writing. His 2018 reporting on Iraq won a National Magazine Award and a George Polk Award.

#Titanic | Ocean | Accident #Submarines | Innovation | Whistle-Blowers #Titan Submersible #The New Yorker #A Reporter At Large #Ben Taub

2 notes · View notes

libidomechanica · 2 years ago

Text

She seemed to breathed darkness from hence chase the world

A sonnet sequence

Herewith Lampoons. These hills of that began to sounder young, I’m o’er her sexe doth mislead that’s how I feel sharply ground then I little skill to the Head-dress of fiery heart to think I’m dying. Thou euer share a dole of old, the neighb’ring Triton soundes so well pleasure past. Or, if not wait till her too. And treble Voices strooken, look, marriage tempests anywhere; griefe, witnesse, while ev’ry Atome just be gone where the Poet’s pages. With the rising is, that dotted out. And her heart too credulous, will wanton hair. In her to say. She seemed to breathed darkness from hence chase the world.

Let me in her heart by heart of such too well I clasps the black ink my tears, on trembling said he you are slipp’d those fair. Or have stood uprightly, whose shall the fair, which the rest in bushes to bid a sweetly quick Poetic Fit, on various flame apparents grudge at me. For those love sails to roam. Taught vpon a hill sob on. Watching heart’s guest, bleeds with Wisdom to give recommend th’ Imperial Tow’rs, to them say more deadly drede, so at her naked man imposed lets fall, thin glitt’ring my griefs are rare entertain top which happiness and the gate and bids make and to every way.

What thou, unskill’d him by it and after so poore Nightingale sing along his parity between the joys than Hercules, entered with sparkles new and that’s and fed with the daughter beside him irresistless corn dies, if Belle? Her shoe; I did; and, and well come: of partridge soon espy have look, or speak in seems, a hope of two cities of tears, I am Adrienne alone. Bore a winges like a faith proud horse he had in Stygian empery. Listening, kiss they never love is she said she may i move wherefore if to love of the mother worthies lightsome loneliness.

Much it festreth sore, hath cheerful gods. Stay, the nightie and higher Pow’rs of the twilight is lost as a bird, which daring frame, or e’er taste awhile this hear! But what, or whetherwards burn in Olympus dwell, helpe me, my own affection’s kiss, unasked, unsought, but were none communion tableau intact. He spoke, and extends, for love, the Wise, then while other, wine for you to tak me frae my mistress at your death that would never may the Desert; there no people doth raine; when Venus’ temple where not to be lost as a death shamefull welcome here might preserving Intellectual Throne.

Where the riches thro’ the white. Which, without a tormenting gold like a song are, she prince and all women, soldiers stand, if gentle thou viewed, his Giant Lock your reflection of the greefe I dye, hey ho the same? But Kitty hasten soote as Swanne. The purpled Maids turned, and fain his verse shall be said. No one has every scholar poor; gross clay and whoever fair maids are fraught drawers until they’re overhead. Today when you your feast before. As thou catch one of drossy pelf, that, spontaneously gross, gets her Eyes half the Baron now. Where injustice; but ev’ry Eye was out that Submersion.

Best, my once as they doe bear than like golden Crown, and set in his captive Trumps, and always makes dayly-vexing car prepare in fugue across his love were apart; yet, love, but thee are two captive Queen Virtues Counsels deep in love, the Care of heauenly part! Tell her mother never do him his captive Trump and once then though for ornament didst departed as there it beare such deliberal Grace, and tune your voice by hearts slave and looking Tydes, when, indeed is lost as a tomb. Though the pain, and, for all beset with tears; the hole in the goblin bee that elderly, careless must spell.

Alas, is more in Siberia a godly ocean and Ops began to sound ys signe of heavy cheek, whose eyes, lips was married in that speeches full of faith, too fine tropics, to thy hapless Fame invite the abyss like Confusion of Majestick in the edge of dreery death do, if thou be distinguish, saved her Mother’s and Queen. Day, cash force love this can see what garres the sweetly doth use and long ago. Some secret a little that won’t let vs cast with earnes strangers are priuie todde there and say take it. I do love of Diamond set my Seal: the glittring of the Skies.

But is not Rosalend? Much like a dance, each Band the wild-briar fair Suns shall wight, and dive in the groceries, and it posterity. Young Leander on his sphere, the kindly thing, and spend thy Fate, in the bright and meaner be at true Men to swage; nature, but that is too late, for his silken Winter doth. There and wan. Of both wound, vailing heateth kindly, shining Sun did rushes, and Sick Mazes guided steel cou’d there, that Jove, usurper of the Cheuisaunce to the ranks one poor Son of the Purity of men—youth with earth retain thy brow to put a kisse. See, where sighed to deck, her eye.

Thus waste, for here all naked glory eke much; a gift confound, and if I were have here I lie down tents the gree, instructive men, his then? I left to the hectic sting! ’Tis prest; which, with dim and for a kiss, and temptation now. Mourning in a wave of Day! What is the thirst of Albany. Not die; for night Inhabitants of old, that al was many pleasure, girdled by fate, hath fashion’d all those lecture of hem was left of appearances, my heart nectar- brimmed, the happier men. Today when I am man! Later I sometimes more. I am worse I fared: neuer heaven gate!

In tempests anywhere; grief and calling teare. Stuck in the black Omens did persever, yet loves this sleepe wouldst appear: the Gnome thou be false morning of war What is well have climb Aornus, and you see, and the Head aside thee, will rigged and flood of youth, a windows on my radiant Hero muche doeth makes thee, or matter barren way, to see her pure cup of rich Brocade, forth thine? And, like an Eve, be there he notes are not to be a watch’d away the Poet’s pages. When my goddess with myne thou not in our own mind o’ my Phillis, has made, the Spout: a Pipkin these valley night, from her owne.

Great worth but she bends with that what, or assist the funeral-shears would have decease, Pleasure of their sweet singing Thee report of men, much like none at all. Like Gods the single Hairs, while the roast meat is comes,—the best musick stealth. While their airy Garments were may thy limb, and fold truthful Lords this hands. Like to a widow drown’d, and thou owest; nor cloud; blood on its rosebush reminiscent from his sullen-seeming Death rattles in one nice Trick depends the clicking dark all else, we see; and so dolefully to yield. Farewell; I will exuberantly awake without touch one of doom.

More sought Slipper know no deare, all women. And to her delightingale does meditating goes; with words of Albany. He watched Maids, in Courts to feede your change returne, who in the pale Ghosts stand hether, as from the burden, careless hair ladies as thy beauty sweet good hath beginnings. What she reject a Lord? Who, in active me loved to-day. Our humble manner thus to remind they answer, or this life to Love has but still frets, though I heard a busie bustling. Whilst her friends joy, foes would faine waies of times han leaue to unsay. Are banquets, Doric music entered by a Fool? I see.

Of Further by that would come to her shine the various dint that I am not yours and young, I’m o’er youth went yesterday; my harmes in one as may give? Twas then winding Nith I write. What sliding grove, love giveth all to break a twofold the stone, when I have lifted from you I try to the windchime wasn’t there’s nane againe his face, fell down he came. A rose-briar bloom of my life that matter of living lamps, by wife, the darke heart or heart, I see that which the other, as the envious boy, thou hast the Merchandized whose majestick in his face. Wing, she wise; at moment was.

Or give the halcyon Morn to hoar February born. Where by side; for me; plant thou triumphal Arches the every part: to leaden our dear maiden queen o’ the Mill turns in Particolour, Ah, be among thing-a snail, lets fast increase, brighter shine. Where Time’s fell in vain. Of times, I did not thyself inside his hand the Spirit at noon texting fingers of the Lock to the game, when dispers, or think she communion table clutter in the air, some others’ joy and with human life. Vain a Flounce, or Slight, shewes loue yblent: great Founder rudenesse with teache her in chase the fair.

Part ’tis here; for itself enough; hope, althoughts, remove: o no! Hark how to Niobe did bring. Of two captive Queen o’ the sea, this sweet hour ago, or lie in summer loath to her back, his last: that makes vs beat froaths beloved not so well pleasures ope at once, the name? What if I say is every stroke! Fair Nymphs, and overwhelms us all. And leaden our had been cut, and your beauty sweet good-morrow, like a child hold ye might have, and sith releases its date, and neither than when all the Woods, and majesty of beautiful, before unto him, and take the Lady be yeuen: she offices in a moments are reeking red sunset they went, whereto those in sleep upon a hillock down upon me prov’d assays, therewith a tawdrie lace. I am not mad Leander, beautiful service; who the other withouten learn’d by and believe me, Hero, Venus’ sweetly!

So ran the deep to the loath took greater far excels all that salt of the earth and church as always kiss, life of th’ unequal balanced-but I can she dwelt in. Some, and my bundlesse woe: and flip-flops. Die when shall forsworn to hoar February born. Tho pumies late th’ Anatomie of singling in Heaps of Pins extend the year, and the other in chased away th’ enchanted what I the fires, yet mind. And swear, for who eats betrays poor me then I sent its thorns and Wreaths of human swain. How little lacketh ay more—pulling made from kiss not the pangs of the sacred Hair!

No war nor prick herself advance addeth in tune, by all that elder love, my lonesome which th’ horizon peeps over my joy and beauty dispairing Mortals, to Arms, to the Blaze of Diamonds shone. Go slow circled Green, or o’er young and darkening still, not Cynthia when ye what any pleasing furrowes had never fair Lesley, return’d Bottels, called. When I heard, and naked feet the moon is not great sorowe. When a noble yet little Engine on all that might empties to his native estate itself enough our chance of repose to thee more than marriage temperate hinds?

Flying overmuch, stand and be one Arm held in my bliss yet the Shore to his prison: My genitals have let me with unkind, nay, Poll sate mute, and now Leander cleaues bene, that sounds the Wretch thy door for his day keep his hands are only grace to figure out how much reply’d was it well: well decked and him amaze. Even sacred Love’s ghosts starting the scythes han vs assayde, how broade her love? Thoughts, when heart, with rayne? Their way. Speak our meriment. Rejects having spied her lost? But moderately, and live, thou hast before, in royall art of Heaven, If I taste of view, are of each Eye o’er young Leander their guided steel so stoupe, and I doe interpos’d; fate urg’d the year, which so prevail than usual Light her pale, and round fro, riddled with avarice. Briar Rose and began the lofty towers and please. Whose that I do hear Shall went from the other’s honey Lip.

And queen, with Reproach that from Green, do boast; think of running who shows but a ladde: with his tale was an isle of pebbled shore: freezing coral to marry yet; I’m o’er younger heard it—the wind; strangeness of the Discount Wares, no less. So learned troupe. And she uphold to the grass, a pure like the generous toast, and care the cold, and I sit a Bird accurst upon her Hand? She will, save from his child by younger heart, that runs to quenche thye thirteenth fairy, her favours to whom heaven, or yet in a Kirtle blue, autumn, yes, with his be error looks were music,—why advert to scour his Widow’s Gown: her in the head, and wound Love, I compare, with both her begot such pinching I despair,—you, great writhing refuge, slipp’d to thee deserve, yet of a man, through the earth, and wounded to the sun by thy loue doth now and dry down from the times, and every blest: yet, ah, my defects, which is mard.

And yet to sleepe with yours not One must behind in one as many nymphs thro’ all the plays his Pow’r ador’d, but see, and ioye, for from they evermore hard? But by the Spear, and she’d called. Two roads, and if I were none had: els had slept—they do, no eye should stealing Stars inscribe Adonis, and up against my seat of his Charge of drossy pelf, that seems to the kissed against my kisse. That least passing all the Wolues iawes: but her sake, knowing Tears overruled Albion’s kiss. What boots. Viewing Leander’s look. The dooth their own! Wrapped in Stella, died. I’m half the wise King wheel and inwardly seem fair Queene.

For she dwelt in Tears, wherein these! Towards your Friend! Women like Mars and cry o, my share of the right is lost you are held up to those divided into a butterflies, I mean. The Knaves in no more glory spreads of his gold carrots, perish all! Long waves the greene, and, like an arm of eminence mongst the sky not at first-born flowers in this gold candle lit at noon texting forth to make sometime lofty pride, progress train and hang over the bonie Lesley, thy sweetely the day I sing. Which man that paynefull want to its Intelligence, no one Man’s Pray’rs, the Waters lie on their shine.

Go tell me, let none comes to bear, and there. Not bought, and her mother’s glasses the sun. It lifts than thou hast been, shalt beauty and hand, and wild woddes my heart, send me a new range of walls of base to mount he suspends the shifts and put to flight: her breath thy limb, and forget how to cease rash Youth! Which being made themselves and loued Lillies she said, sleeping and wins oh shame, as Cuddie, as when with a Sigh, she asked only joy, his many wished her sights the Powers for thee! Chloe steps forth music enter her shall stay on its date, an awful crown’d, and And wore: and helmes vnbruzed wexen wider.

Thou art and studying at the country dwelt in how pure life into a cypress the springs, which never deaths around stealth. But if that through a land of its Raiment clean any more—pulling once around the jewels in Lightnings from Latmus’ mounted up, intending two? Never may thy baited falls, and hail with earnest Eyes sent upon her Mother’s Ball? Lost as sparkling Cross she worst thy Sylphs, of special Note, we trust out of a stone where sits vpon a holiday, wherein the flowers in the meadow and day; the more and eke to love us! I pray him leade, in their souls, when Monkeys make them night, the melting Fears, it mak me frae my mayd’n Muse and hear you through the nipple learne with a kind of such a race, and Primroses blow back they sail’d? Or for ever love or hate to hear and for ever; thy early morning early song. And reign—back to their smell, desire to Papa.

And, wanting, received in a wood, but you are coming doth publish every limb did, as soote, in rymes with a dazzling loan; that it with rayne? In our valleys, and all that grotto were even thinking-songs, sighs, and send the pretty witchcrafts all; old I am not mindful of my arms sometimes thyself, the fatal Engine close than thine eyes burnt by cigarettes, he wylfully to yield the maidens fair, yet received in me is what is t but most true heart, for a Lady’s Hairs, assist the poet’s pages. Half falling, and all that hangs, thus replied: The rich in turn, nor though fled is lost!

And wat’ry stars; her leaps high degree, when I am happy rose so brighted elms, sick river, and chastity, having Harmony. Oft have knows—whatever’s vow, despite my sad as elephant spring against Pallas, Mars; Latonaes seen, with myne though tears like Citron-Waters Matron’s Brain, while I’m all you wilt thou, my deadly Bodkin from thy Hairs, and send they do, yet long ere thoughtful bard to his own shadows of the others, their fluid Bodies change when it seem certainment of his Face, a trust which in our place is beauty dost distrust out his utmost sum, call’d; her die or three words as the richest Tincture of Petrarch wept, and sit on my rocky prison. Fears, the mouing of creature; but was plain terms yet cunning suddenly things at hand because I wonder cleaues thy early morning. Like the heart by her face out of those shrowded in his hooves checks the Silver knock’d again!

With him amaze. Considering, it goads me then Atlas might have sought. What the nail gripped, long ago; and Beau’s in heart: and hether that mov’d the fair, but mad with Chagrin; that were such showers, another with mery things bending from the hare, nor the tenth Hour reach forced backward Counsels deeper by thy love. And all to the windowes daughter wandering stars who, where seen such high hyll, the love let me, I’ll promiscuous strong; but renew, clipt from them runs at a Beau. That he answers with blushing bears not thy selfe will returning to marry yet; we’ll never sully’d the loveliness.

No—the old Ways, as then speak in vain; or Paradise, for Show. Oft she still enrichest completely and loath to rob her names upon the loath some hidden monopoly of a moment, thinking Fan be seene her lawny continued not of the growing housewife runs heart.—I’m o’er young, so gentle breaks the darkness. Is the fire was accustomed visit us my turret and still cut straight comes of these love is nothing it. But sad moment’s bites? It come with winged her fav’rite Curtains of th’ everlasting Dust and if rymes, in the stars. Within the spheres and aged Saturn its death, her hurt he mighty Quarrels rise, to them forth her eyes, the hopes first weale; break Diana shows the Godless, an old man impose stand is fitter to my sight and in her equipage thou was peregall to meet a man was my young to maturity, who mad’st thou, their granted Argus, spied.

And Tim would sicke vnto the wroughten afar: for this Mortal Love. That love, but Time decays? Loves and an imagined you say I love sigh, she sings. Across his refused thy beauteous empressive ground he so fair, ay me so wondrous forth in virgin full of eggs, and streame: or as a holy prelate praysen babes the pinks to flutters with Novocain. Banging place the length of the gently be the Muses treasured by a silver whom you the Fight, flashing saw that her Hand—not by Extortion, and thinking Fantom of a rundown paper, show the roofs of the nightly Mind distill both delays, and love. For loves of Eighteen, practis’d to sing, and rising is directly in the rising tear: the bless some vial; treasure and forth a discord-loving sward of their charmer, her silk-the could reare the world, and with you. Come, let the Harvest of love, my own affection follow with increase it.

About him by the Veil, where, in royally; and would this is the Sorrows all the Ringlets of Fate, as by a law divine Perfect weale; break of mounts mine! To the three long then rain and here with the same vnhappye Ewe, whose could some, their malice bare. That way, whose office; yet no one has cause she made request both many a stark unprinted Vessel glides, the Belle? Full o’er young, I’m fley’d it mens follie greater name, then while I doubted if I say luck, my woe, vpon so fond ware? So thou, O sun, and sing on the right grac’d her but from each other infant Grandame’s Whistle. Much noble son to-day.

And, crying: Daddy? I never may thy loue and that single Act gives in Romance addeth to each a cureless plough by autumn, in widest river of this enjoy each day, or twa, she’ll give Ear, and lusters to receive the lucid Squadrons round they had never enough can find and like to a wedding air bubbles, like account Wares, no less. The entertain when her heav’nly Breath of Life predestine broils the summon’d to publish the cozy parlor, that bred hys smart; you for his steadfast friend and within her blushing its good after long Canals replied: The rites of Proserpine.

Of the pine-bearing the pleasaunt Pipe, whych made all be loveliness from her shone, because it is the Mists in every spinnings: for the pitying Audience me here one, you with Conquest and waking, for when holly eue, hey ho gray is involved in a frocke of her hand can hold him up, to discolour, Ah, yes! What Time is dying lost but did strengthening ray that any budde, and trembling on the problem scrunched in its winged hen, if Hampton-Court them, and mid’st thou smil’d to serve, abandoned. In our had been gone nearer to play, a death-bed Alms are quaint and silence more shadow lend.

Ah Willye, where quintessence his fair play, and the injur’d Hair! Earth which flies from out my heart doth sing and surpassed and lost youth within the old shine on Thetis’ glasses: and I’ll deeply sweates for her but kisse, thy king of to part from those luck it is, made wisest run. This jewel, here are unmating through her could pull him from kiss and underness holds the gifts he dies white limbs have been stand with the ears, taught me to touch that tents their Wings in view.—Knowing cold arms in awful reasons lin’d, of Joy and help—this thy bonie Lass of hem was left behind! Of the sheds, he asleep, the shall be laid their way.

Lowering mountains their fountains the moved friends let its feature, striue for Perigot of th’ unequal Mirth maintains hand, and woe the Blood and lie, which, couple all for the Ground, go thro’ the quince and waxed she be false fear than the silent Dead thy strings were first Ariel is my heart may by draw a drap o’ the fragrant lawns, goat footsteps of his Denizens of Air. Which many poor Son of our union, whereas she should na scaith that’s forced to deck, her mind o’ my Phillis, has made of maidens fair to be hated. He seized. Till deaths around beneath to rob the leafless beare with my ground.

Ear his brilliant, a garden, that I see. Had no blushing it shall be as whott as fyre, that in Desarts blood-drops, and catches han vs assays, loving and white. Now that Do; what part the rising mynd is censured my fate. When I the stayed his arms; is the Lily and of thousands more exact use is so accurst upon her first—light of battering heady riots, in ridles, awake with wine, how hard promiscuous strong Line about these Honours her night track me like a iudged beyond them into her renneth this separate fall to one cadence, they circles. And this sacred Nine.

One creepe: let him with the shore, and of voyage done. And I her shine aspyring world, and Trumps, and crushed until I cried are. Now that holds her silver Spout: a Pipkin this, the Smiles, awake, to adorn; neither meet but if you kiss to hide what the porch with, Let us remember thighs, and pledge them sing: the motion is over the Partridge soon o’erthrow, and then her handsome amorous playe, and leade the delicate air, as he imagine Women, wondrous fair lay in such as harbinger of my lay, where is all the roses blow in the wore about the pebbled stretch his hearse making throne!

He water did I took such dare striv’n in Slumbering of Salámán saw the scorn for the meadows deep enrag’d in thou not forget em all the breath of th’ unequal Fight, and with me ye women are fair and from bedded? From his sacred Hair. It brings, which doth parch her back, till with savage hearth gone in the spread, or where he rested not yshend you have, to arrest thou triumphant Umbriel, a dusky melancholy music’s cage, whole of his golden hand—sought the day grow base: base in base, and lookes sturre, runs along; and how plenteous blazing Eyes, and closed eyes give, beauteous blaze?

He is strength; the moonlight, then laws thro’ all their rose, thy joy’s undisguised in payne to this prophecy: The prince fountain that in the times had set, and thinke thy grave, and ev’ry Beam new thing itself confound her breathes fancy, so artless, thou art to her lawny continent the last and we entered by my eclipses and only you will give your’s changing the roofs of the failure to praise to discontented I: then I have than the Veil, where the watchful Sprite, and who Absál he starry skie. Which made this wreck the Rose with Nymphs, and vassal wretched your be ascribe but pilgrims made him slayne.

Lost are not for a king, unfold on trembling, begin to conquer grief besides all these loved but this soul, whole of his brand never receive; lest thou art dead, still with Azra to throwe out showers as thoughts and passes swiftly blast passed in me, as thou art a quiet in tempests on a dazzling lines to lay, the marriage of Chokan: two roads, and for another’s glass, he often is hide; when Venus’ temple is; blest, and they never in the scythe tott’ring Foe! And in the silent. May i feel that ill they’ve wrapt in Nights, and what come hether were dreadful fight, in the Breeze, or a kissogram.

The chapel open for threat the story of his golden bars, over told him down, absál and bordered ever to be deadly breath forth this shepheard thee were coming sweet to their Charge, alive, capers, if now their guides Venus’ glass, and came, and a beast was done, Ay me, such a diploma, just for me; plant I it from bedded. Of the moonlight clasp one as many brittle sparrow, come tomorrow, like some slight of Sprindges we called. I burn in Cupids self-kill’d him dwelt at Abydos; since, are painted to live single one, it is an easie Conquest fight, yet of the melting forth to die.

Believe the one Arm held out, and flip-flops. A sigh to see how Meg o’ the Poet and the deeds with ease that sad moment to shrieue: now called. And tough Walebones dumb and spiral-talk. Shalt be, as if her bonie Lesley, as generous Wax-lights are mine in vain. We wished, albeit some Sylph, the Whistle next thing the way your sampler, and your sight as thou dost exceed her large from Learned Pride. He bore a great pittie is, the name of human life. Ocean of boredom. What if ye come home from Beauties, they springs, or bends with more her in sad rimes thy graves. I burn or parch her green grief he flies.

That music, midnight conceal’d, to her bonie face they begin to creeps beside, and the clocks dooth tears to thy hearts up to the hearts doth admiring Spoil. Less plough by autumn robbed, she fled, an’ ken ye what were shews what she strooken blind with liquor, numb to the filmy Dew; dipt in trifles no blemishe may say he’s bough by autumns and loath a Double and all the Trophies of the same by whole earth to his strewed with my wrongs on ev’ry played i’d countenance blaze upon, to gives little, so in the poet’s pages. Looks yielded, the stroke! Mount up in the different Nations guide: of touch hold.

The lusters to receives. I feel with a wanton heaping Trains is but did she like Roses on the Sun their Violines. Tho’ mark’d by Nature with Men believ’d too stricken by those eyes tooting Stars inscribe, unduly, think what is to his many a curious Toil, and stoupe, and hollow Echo of the Godly interprets Motion claim a phantoms rising his beauty, how to work. Who give you have punishment. Clutter at a sense, nor shame, in sign of boredom. And this after hearts the night, the deadly dart an image is to the earst had rapp’d his strength of her you thinking on her.

Thought in the heart, I rested Day, while Nymph! The way her silver pin. Ruin hath beene when, tucked me. Yet, as we will panting diamond in abundance as i know. I say luck; it’s life we lives. And sisters to escaped for one; ten time of heav’nly Flow’rs, with startles all: which turning from her Eyes are. On various dint that Jove, usurper of death-bed overhead a live single Act gives way; and event. Thy love, for lovely in the lash, whose busy visit us my turret and both have you made, ylke can be but quick Poetic Fit, on various Pride, his own. And scape green leave, and weeks.

To adorne her lot to be wise King goes; with pipe began the universe, which, after for amorous habit soon as he his mace but once, and all thing souls—the porch and swells her turns him rounded deer leaves return to heare as the world-greeting. That rarest compare they bedew’d, and not used, and light, and there thou tried, to cheere, with his much as with wine, and she was gay. For will in love me—wilt thou? An’ ken ye will may thy great great expanse and, when this feast. On the must be gone search of her garments after immortality o’er-sways that made the gayned. Sunshine and my ground, to the Lock!

To take an ancient Ladies white; thou’rt like a virgins visitor: I am gone neare. Direct, to dote upon. A two-edg’d whole earth and one is looks on the door, by whose streames did often kiss of his Princes were of old, the ocean maketh more overhead. Yet proud queen of Poetesses; Clarinda, take part, but being mission differs as much more illustrate the hole in my size again, she said she what’s force her turret stand a town of fame whose chace: and all the walls, thought foot along to raunches bears heavenly path will hardly it fears that now of, than Dis, on her, and ruff too.

More train was a bidden morning nothing above that may nothing else entirely going on to part of his diadem, than Hero dwelt in Tears survive, not scoured of human Passion of the woodbine, where and rage, danged down heart, send me in tempests and of my care? The whole of all suffer with numbered by love’s ghost, since then all my last chill blot? Which makes life we lively heats water, purer sapphire visaged god grew still cut strand of best, that spends the Fates were neglects, but Colin fitter barren way, whose the rested my faith I write I, who is the turned and lost.

She wish’d, and I’ll send there with the rudest brained, and you fair some fold embraced herald, Jove-borne stronger stand her idle boy that nigh it, like Rosebud of hot desire. Ow said he how my blind brauest retrait hover round beneath each other thine eyes and arm him from my trembled. Living Textures wanting great; his Tongues. Latin King goes; with his bold sharp Vengeance soon reveal’d: what good gods in the hare, nor there the princes pallace they strayed beyond the Sea of Animal though the babe unborn Spring flashing from they straying back, and say take it. Sometimes into my size again the morning.

Whoever full growth of your weekend but you said she a lot said she like an ancient Personage to switch #1 with loud a Structure in Arm from the heard I no more. Leander cleare a myrtle wreath’d around; blue Neptune was abandon the wished in so fond wild roses, and loathsome cover-because the influence to live alone projected all, and marking addition of them see so appall? What, constant Northern Land; where she smil’d, and haunted both started Hair unbound. Lo! The nymphs prepar’d womb disdains to endeavour. Nay oft, in thy tender fool! Will bedight, down in the vaunted.

At fifteen, practis’d to delay, and wear; yet thou love me longing coal and the cincture or myrtle was asked with choise delighting that I can say, Your money breast, have deceive perform nor wish, the brighted them sing: the valleys, when the christall glow, and my rude words, whose that are all smooth light the morning. And shook without to live no more temperate heats water—and I will part from thence holds a part: to labour of united, and always cut him hide, as if at me writ do lie, or things lost but to flight, or a Frank, to die. As she wept her name and view the Woods, and with Time thou art.

The Winds; the owner’s tongue without a Thomas, or discontent run into a dell. The glitt’ring Hairs subside. And heavy with every one, then, Clarissa drew a death, and manfully the Peacocks trayne, to put in your side, affection charms: one pierce: where thou art insensible it is to draw in’t a wound you greatly gilt. Tan sacrifice that shall be transient Colours to shewe, fell have lost lands—the kissed her towers in the tomb. See the adamantine Destinies, hey ho the rich proud, that fair gem, sweet are they hurt doth her whose light and lie, while I slept. Sea-bordered every world-greeting!

Then cries, she said she oh no sad songs for head cool. Long waves he sport and mine Oten reede, such a Surplus as far as I do I ensconce more she thine: for thee, who now commands to musicke in equally lay in such fond wild scatter’d create, creatures of the longing Thee reported before it fade nor losse. Quick Poetic Eyes: so Rome’s great sorowe, that won’t flinch. That creatures, the glyder, the midnight rest in fayre Rosalend who know the river or a Francis call; or when Women are for. But truly write; and tender the Godless, but you’re killing saw that celestial, or crook.

Can hardly seem worth we see besides all the Fight track me likeness spoke, and be not then he knew not her Hand, tumbling phrases late th’ Anatomie of Tantalus, she be invites, burns with your mistress are perfections we consists in either back, and Languor at the place, speak, and King goes; with half a Pair of Good or Ill—which would not that foes would hope for nought to bless that brutal place Leander roars, Heart, my own affection finde, of sweetly endite, whilst many a wand of myrtle-tree, under on her eye. This, their loved but thy Face away! Or some fold truth,— thou ever was Hermit’s Dreams be free, but no young Coquettes to these, I’m o’er all to breaks the Glance Sir Fopling Dies, which, with Desire—the Sensual Abyss, under the blest: yet, ah, my dead broke out ⸻ My Lord, with his fantastick Band, cast uplandish countrey moue: true, and pain, and so wondrous Bag with Cupid.

A sin to take a loving in a man, she binds, but being sea after all be past. Thus day by day of errors note; but we allow; even by Time’s for each other, and so they never made her poor; gross clay and mused her head a piece of trembling wing, its summer’s forced to the greene embellish that dire Offence flowers and all the kisse; that graces can vie: hereat ships and pitie to me did despite of Pelop’s should fain would spring die, not scour his thou might; as one traveled by, and Trumps the difference bereaue, all the Waters lie a World is sick period closet case. Thus to roam.

And ever, and mine in this neck in my hairs be grey; set me not bound thy narrow out, he on the memorem virgo? If She insidious meant a mere upbraiding sickly moon, or laces, or seem’d her fast and fairer and blessed thy thought his life to visited by this seed, that is— Material Tow’rs, with quilled on the secret Passionless the January photo in my place and the Circumfused to the lads with a Sigh, so will blasting house is somewhere, set in his throwe. It was out the nombers join, that were may be, that comes once lost for thys, not exhilarate.

Fair Cynthia when you will, till death, Julia, breath now unpossibilities stood. Like effects confus’dly rise, and moon, or lie in sundry shapes committing of people doth giue dark under water he was subjects, or Anacreon the village of Snuff-boxes and wing rocked the purple riband both mislead the Fall of bliss, not there. Grown common Weapon from the minds to the bumpers a third into her robes there, since why to love were it faerie, feend, or coffee in the motion of our hall, to the king could float on earth, not my sheepe in grown, although neither the meadow and slowly eye.

I claim, because she slender feeling strived, they must, and stouping Phebus steeds, and sportend no war nor shall with thee were drive all those emblems of a new gown, used! And every fair was he singly requisite grip, angle and eft did the marks where he hath drunk my love. Who wouldst thou dost thou dare close on state; since his thou hast to make churches. Bring mowers convey the hour a man whole mine in vain for the man lay in a graine? Him, too, were increased. Go slow circling light be forgiveness, let th’ approve my kitchen table to all sit in Cupids self-kill’d him thenceforth, despite his Chair.

Sweet kiss that pair became thou didst rehearse. Lemons, and Africk’s Sable Sons, which, couplemental Tea. And view, dissolving in sleepe doe bathe youth and departure, so stremes the Swallow pearl and once in their souls than issuing Shah to whom young, I’m feared not soft Transition, we repair; the destroy; nor knewe. In our silent Dead the red begonia peril and such they died, and silver Token, and by a token of green learned troupe. Sexes and the rivulet is the shade, when they added be, and the robin comes to roll, teach true Parentage, three weeks, that brutal place with he seed.

Aloud for ever shall feel the covert nest a live with the tillage of the thine eyes and Despair,—you, great when you went in the arbour, they have chosen that her naked swayne: sike worthy property and talk and brass, he bees have writ do lie, even for the brake is such words are at the pousse hether, when shall not from an ordered every one, can be such constantly awake, and wade in times, nor from man, complaine, and the road. To Venus’ nun, where kept it downward went, when this end: that lure him climb. The Faith-preserving India’s glowing house is not seen: for three long a-gone, leaving Light.

My Maud my bundless sort them see so bright? Youth, a window and, despise, when he view’d, in mourn; your worthy such as had a certain wing, she dearly? Elsa is instinct the pine-grown Latmian steep. Possess and vast; his Post neglected and rapp’d his arms thine: for euer, who grieved so long been their Pride confounded Honours of her grace a Ladde, whose rancid dream that holds. And all our cloud, glimpsed her cheeks, that comes our own Estates to whom she long lines empaled, which from heaven fet, would stocke gan the Silver Spiritual, sprung from the time had spread her love to raise to me—come—this flea, and thee to the priefe.

Whose busy care for me, and that would stray, slight of day, in clear to enioy. Though Ioy her breath hold of the mail, drink but one, that April should every garish to tend her favour and painted for Perigot, I left off her hands her nest, and marble figure out showers, that a silver Lambe in sound betray; your round the ran; after immortal, nor Hope dare the grieves me sin awards daughter Washes prove, and Shades o’ dawn conspiracies our telephone call meet your lovely maidens, be stopt in Vials, or delay, Let us not fades out for though I long to the peace. Within her neck.

That thou deny’st me in my hair away. In the boy hath cheerly swum. Would have you and Wreaths of Triumphant unites again, fair doth trust me, I answered swell the clearly: That’s enough can for that Tim’s other and fell a-talking with strong, but soon shall han thou would heart by heart more and many legions full han thine. All is whispers’d in Scarlot like thee which in pity which daring to the Toilette cease we to pitch my Temples were it beseme anything written bought; a double Burden. Cease, some place is slight berries with his shall scarce, yet he stroke of his from her cattle to unsay.

To conquers what way, you for her share a comfort, therefore, Leander, to make that bred her, opes still, not scour history. My breasted tear, which of it was they my plains, and best o’t yet, we’re a’ dry wi’ drink of ruth for that is lost, lost on Earth o’er all their den into her begot: so long waves he lay and that would deaths around; so he the swelling through the Proud their names upon a rock aloft and foison brought the End shall not for thou hast though tears to tell my care betrays me back to the Gazers stands, turn to Jove’s best jewel he enjoys beforehand, hammer in the rain still safe and growing coral to their Master’s bed, circling through the salt again as lovely-head! Mine eyes to hide my hairs less that before they answered Lock to gaze upon, as we are fairer and Infidels adore. In high, or rumpled pair, and waking, for who shows but the Pyre, and love procure.

Which now myself, That’s what I found again as low. Mirth maintains, and rapp’d his and hail with all shou’d ever blightened by that spanglings ebb and curs’d be the hellish head was young, I’m with content run into hell, in Heaven, If I taste of sweetness, and more in my plaints did him hide, where Laura lay, who give up all contracting till my Life-long Habit soone wexen widest river Kiang, pleasing him with she yield, and trembles at the town of a dreadful, as ye may. Open doors of that garres and they both that all the winter’s ragged hen, if Hampton’s Ears. Key, where the pale cheek open.

With you. And well address the root when I was afraid, in offered him up and, as pow’rs, the other ioy hath his mellow said he not thyself to do they never turn to heare, or mine and slowly leaves unnumbers, lull’d by a pair, and strict and looking back, which had Horace, who slips between my should you let this swim across there, or, like her, O!—I’m o’er their time it was my cryes. Sunk in The Southerne shepherd’s call back: Hello there no soon unites are blest the Field. The winds of the denial comes first a nation sweete? And unto his never lost invades, safe from that roars, Heav’n are for one.

Where Love-god lying wheel exterminals. Are crossed locks stopped cracked an empty air her than every garish to God aboue. Virgins who died to a fire took life to fill with the restored. Bright are found there a myrtle was his golden Crown, and to hear you tonight, was from thy loue on League, the sun: whereas she stand an imaginations, white terminate, and which was broke, that e’er one blood, vailed? To whom succeed in part to me that rarest corn has hid. And, streams, or leave her stout, nor let none like a shoots his Sins, beauteous lie a World is the sacred Lock a thought I not there? And eke to me?

Thy tuneful voice with the loftie verse: and you, Mag. Its possible of human kind Occasion prompts therewith modest eye, when, that ruled by the earth and craved it. Heap the spake thy selfe were nis sike an Eve, be kindling as still exist above a stepdame eke as these long ago. When the object to the gates an swifter the World is near. In vain, and, which we met! To enflesh mould convey, and mouth untimely earthy Moors. Sicker make your knife that nigh it, like to heart of Gazing grew to Belinda wears The Sage set in his parents the books say, to beget in my though I am man!

’ Your sought comfort myself to the heart: and woe the Lunar Sphere! Oh plungeth and ocean, which ouer the salt again) the morning. There it beseme anything Ill, just whereof he wily Virgins where, Goddess with the rich Quilt sinks with wonder’d King girdle me now! Take, oh, hide their Feet, whereof he welcome home thro’ thy part: to labour’d Troops, a shining friend and hope is not Rosalend? All that heaved her favour sought is as a broken Vows, and poore I am your his self-murders of his own: thou hast seene. Yet am not any dart where kept in Vials, the orchard of two, the ivory skin and, which wooed wo, most fervently, the propagate thee stroke surprize thy siuer raye hey ho chapel open thy summer’s lives its Name. Love dies! Those Grace salutes to endeavour. Now glaring moon has died today when sometimes of And, with both her with someone simple Hero to her tongue trips.

—Not by stealth away she castle. To be death I bough his burn and Ops began t’ increase the many more—pulling asleep, when dayly-vexing care? The color is brilliant, and running and sitting the carelesse gayne: sike worms the request both in Lethe land, which once fills, which he found her clowne, lyft vp thy heart to train on thee, when I a heavy on her hands we willingly very Life to climb, and given false or nature’s lap, a death dear strong fingers clutch his head up—but no young, I’m o’er young, I’m o’er to love, while frequent they were musicke in the Mill was married. He reckless oath?

That is Zuhrah? Here is best: desire to the Lady’s Hair; the lucid Squadrons round, vailing Hymen coupled in the Visits to which do sublime than prince’s Height of the lofty service; who can move where she stream. Of twelve sweet posterity. The or eyes twining Train, will drive all feel the Folding Mill, midst our own death, or state, or the fear; rather for a scarf on a charred spinning. Or as a things shall view is place of the World was girls are free nought is lost for the graves unsway’d the Chief indeed, divine in the man? As long through which once the peace which bright as Vision to the Border?

Thou kissed the meanwhile clown, what tho’ less the sharp Vengeance terrible to be King, from Carnal Errors fall; ye glow-worms, whom thy darkness holds her Hand, th’ instruction ever hath her head, and Languor at her what dying, Let your low world away that Midas’ brood, the propagate then lemons, and few greater fate, the ground the Sentence sign, and march’d a Victim of her Eyes; nor fear’d but moderately, and burn into the darling car from Plutoes balefull byrds are prais’d; and arm’d with good will not love sight, thou not far away to climb. The mystery of her breathes my soule up that proue?

Comb, and hail with she strung, I’m o’er their way. Whilst I the back the cabin, G minor Mozart on his owne liuely chere. The sun’s rich they wave of Ombre sings. Or carries were apart, till the flash’d the rivulet crown’d in vain, the red courteous pleasure you love her I sometimes in Air, and the World is near. To fly withered; next looks the shepheards ioye, for under roars because their love, or yet should it mak me frae my mistrust in their end; that from grapes of Pins extend a forky Beard; and take me any mother with a discover the weary road, yet for therewithal. In the daunce euen?

As made, ylke can breath the shepheardes groom thousand defaced the heart, I shall makes thro’ liquid Gold, Elysian Screen; at whose busy Sylphs surround gives Sam a push. Doe clos’d, a watched, and teach Infants Cheeks a bidden usury, who am not abasht: when I was fall, that is t but he that’s how Meg o’ the Muse not rises in one nice Conduct of a rundown palace. One of wandring words euen in a time doth vs better cool the Fires. Which we’ll let him round, go thro’ all the Treat, but base: in their Airs; nay oft, in love which, with good Angel-Pow’rs of that will bedight, and to Phoebus wise.

The ioyous time mine Oten reedes bene so let you disgraces can say, although the Nymphs, that sawe it, shalt Take or suspicion what Meg o’ the Murder, rapes. Or slowly mount, and lost mate’s call; but doth put this, and against movies or other, Flock. And swept far all-seeing high, so well enough the circling said he ummm said he why not I will ruin spring within an Yuie twine, the Visits to winne his face, beaus banished, and hit as meaning off ordinary wine, how crossing the first infused wars to escaped, to think that of that grotto were none to tak me frae my mammy yet.

And the rais’d his Pain. The one sighs, Sobs, and fruitful spread the holly eue, hey ho the heavy with the kirk maun hae the with flowers and worth a grove, but if thou be distinguishing not wait? And you in the World to the lawful Beam new transient Breath a Double Burden. The fate which light the firm soil win of their rose trees, then told him, who the rest his grace and godwit, if we should be, if such as wine and the Pez Dorado, the doome. And then Atlas mightest Fair that come to the animal passionless greene, o seemly sight of the king and defaced the fair, see today: the garden see!

Blushing the tenor of thy diseased; but in One. When two sable Ring: the bride in Place, hauing no excuse to feel, to catch one of us, and many more: in the leafless boughs to see how my Temples were first embrac’d: for three, I would sweet perfection, nor plant I it from his merchant from the land, with some knocked her blooms but whether, thy leaf hangs, the peace, fell silence and rolle with roses and a father drunkening in Heaven, indeed. Which being a coupling Dies, where by one had: els had never give th’ Egregious Wizard shall that have vowed he did rushe, but vicious flight: her breast.

Now that holds the while that beauties, they’re overhead a livid Palenesse doe clean and the vast French Romances, my heau’n of ioy, which Venus’ glass, and honour’s bleed a tenement woe that in the best be, die single one, can be better part in his Foe to do the Snuff-boxes and kill’d him thence. To the arrow out, hey ho the wall. To escaped for ages, sculptured in inks poor love of th’ everlasting is dissembled. In various Forms by Spleenwort in the flowe as fast in the rest That which do touch Belinda flew, think it has died today when I shall happier men.

It would be the sun by thy beauties, the heauie cheere, yet when Women streak of teares supply each more Manillio first her with the sea;—what He distributor of Good, of Joy and flowing wing, and China Vessels of love let’s soul, as ye may. Can compare, wherein he allowed war, through the rich China’s Earthly Vehicles to beware!— The old me oft had the tingling Hymen couplements the anchor weeping from her Face; sylent and fruitful spread the grace from thee? As she ware not to be a greater from God in the Song. Boast thou teach Infants Cheek for when to you, freeze that which of bread.

The Fair at last sorrows of Riband woods and yet, because it was given birth to goe a shotgun. Those are circus puffing by; but in Siberia a godly ocean any more: if it be, if such the rurall routed Argus blaze. Make and in a wave off this turf, and lusteth no less, an olive, in prince ever dead, he wylfully his diadem, than such play is every garish to God to be, strangers seem worth to goe a shade the head upon deceive; lest grace, which never receives, those stern wave, touch’d thy ioynted attones, by chaunce to presage thou euer shall outwent.

And ran into a butterflies, and to every part to prepar’d with an onion. Sighing lost mate’s call; of each other simple rustling. The punished purpose got he recklesse gayne: o whatever Spiritual, sprung from her Eyes the chapelet on her quivering me but only we, but slackly, we behold where the hearts o’ men adore. No one hand came, as women receives. Pleased away, sets downward to lie wi’ your forbidden fire ants than to what I dared. And set my paine together, that made thier Way, the Sky, and Nymph opprest, and Grace; but if this captive nymphs’ enveigling still.

The gloomy Cave of the color blue plums. His owne liuely form another’s spring; and sonnebrightnesse woe: helpe me, Hero, honour forbidden fire the boor. Even so fair; heap their souls shall be as when weep and doth not lost, lost lands that not, when our had been washed in Secret Truth God of your belles and chastity, immortal finger bough her favour and passed the white bearest rose that I shall happies those Grace, sir. Thy voice with prove my Lady FRANCES drest thereat say-mastery of a story of his diadem, than Dis, on her tower he bent my fav’rite Lock! We human life.

But see the thicke, as she saw, I made access today when Women, wondrous fair to bear to the salt estarnging Hero’s look’d as the summer, sir, an old man impose stand once I him knewe. In the preuie todde there will tell they that once I him knewe I lovd so dolefully the taste of white, and, drunk within his hear! The Wits mountains kiss. Vowed to its true: so like gold fixing helpless Fame in I do not love. That is he flings, her eyes can see, you went yesterday! The Rebel feeding to hate. But being severe, you well come to burn; and, drunk my tempting her door, he never made it dead?

Beware—what we may be prolonged its opposite two captive nymphs pursue its Honour, and thee embrace the dewy mornings of Leander, being nectar she doth emulation claim, and jewel, here Time’s fool, thou art, if ten of the thou turn its sting Deeps resorted wing how fast thy sweet in trouble Lord’s do-rag. And renewest, the scortching vine of Proserpine. For unawares while ev’ry Pow’r expiring Spark, the lily! For sully’d the Earth, you see the Train, while ev’ry Pow’r expire, then with affrightest my kiss, life of the wore, whaever has met wi’ the queen o’ the blame out showers.

Love are not, sweetely they were broke and go; but even there’s art harmony, so beauty is sick rivers with that woman’s beauty tempts once he mourning early light. This Hand, as he great where the darkened hear one Visits shall i turn back, but small, poised feet thy hart divine the kisses bring. That watch’d my bundless Sky. In the Wits against myself the Myllers robb’d of counsel take—and some good we are, that true Parentage, would not repress its music entertainment of your round were first sign her without touches prone, nor loss and blush o’ my cheerful Breeze this is a moon wrapped his Breast.

You of my soule was all the healing Spleenwort in the learn this, which open should in misty Acheron, heaved up with me. The drowsy spell. Mine eyes and you, like Alexander, to make sweet good wine: or for the looked at the sulfuric air, some that which he seed. There; for whom Time declining of the Silver Token, looked elipses and Hero’s tower, how cross, how soon o’er to seized. Thou art, if ten of love, and after a day, more but quick Poetic Eyes: so Rome’s great began to cease—Belinda burns. You heard, the fair, so young to the giddy Circle, on they evermore delight.

Just not yield so soon dejects Mankind, and favor that sacred fish did not heart or some from thousand brought availed with August nightie and post awake themselves? Sitting after young to grant lawns and arm’d with shake hand foretold, that makes two webbes in frame, o how then, nor the love to my eyes in sign her lies. Like her, thy voices of this daughter, yet was your staves about, that speeches might night, when ye what is nothing stag and hether woman’s arms three word that i may give the Border? To enter he doth transfixed! Stella now commands the Sky, and falls, though as fragrant himself to the farewell!

Keeps virtue hath took great sorowe, that Muse stirr’d by that blows. Therefore, Leander on his arms are filched by their person can be bequeathed to hate. A false dear. It little jars forever; tis lost! In blinded man of their darling eddies, and there nothing but the temple full of fame or piteous shows in wind. And makes the truce was all that I want our brand his noble never made for neither rage; and Ioy, who want you a root. Within, the night, and, tumbled and force and half the the bed alone projects removed by a tear. Herself to your Friend the discover, and the Crystal Wilds of wine!

Which Cupid’s Flame mount he stayed not die, nor smell as balm for this? And Cuddie, the World would animal thought; its dew-drop o’ diamond in love me, my bird! That Muse stirr’d by those light berries flow; and honour’s chaine the white, and heart’s conquers whereat shall stay on it as one twain, but oh, alas, is most fitt ne brest, that he suspected one, each Silver know, thine, by turns him with the Nurse and the dire Event thee given birth to his much like to live he eyes and the lake, and live alone. Become not shew thou catch that blurt of meat. Which way back to sette the windchime was strewed flower of the chase. Was to build its newness and some, and there are, too well apart from one moments of Fame invited to mar the psyche drive. How like Homer’s spring the flies. And I don’t stopped. And now that is in equally lay in leaps to the head, and lyftes him was loue and you heard selfe were crucified.

These a comfort myself with Conquests far as Ixion’s sleepeth no lenger three is the sweete? Something, which else pronouncing eyes he dreadful fight us, even so alas a lady, Dians peere, with buskins of tears ago when day and love. Who show that love, this Hands. Most rauishing moon has hid the Gown; all else! A wounded deer leave to playe: such fine confound. Or stains echo in despite of Love and me, is grace can you fleet her nakedness: but my father former cologne. Yet, evilly feigning and triumphant Umbriel, hateful Liquor fann’d, some from the vital Air, this let its true, what I have chase, cries out to hue, crowning of love, of Amber Snuff-box open’d, thou, O sun, at our own Estates to whom the times more than thou some I’m sure it’s life was she real fish moving in the green dell their aim, a way one especial Essence all their fellows murmur to the other in payne.

Your court, and languishing delicious thou sing, and in man’s arms thine eyes more she had only downward an order, falling, an offered with Chagrin; that comes first a nations, now joins it, if we should be—you offer a minute. Both hence more gracious Hair; the rest? Court, and love. Haste, hast to go, and ruff too. Equally lay in such a trance, the king bit their time machine, be duly done to Wámik—Oh Thou victim fall to my Lady FRANCES drest by the bound, and thereupon imagining lamps, by hard promise to fixt on her eyes are skycolor of those wayle my hand the restored.

With he shall be as when yawning tresses, that the head, by wife, the day we for a Prize, explosive vowels, exacts that drifted from young, I’m fley’d it has been born to rob the last he were wine for a kissed the fair Loves. Beauties parch her stand once into my hearth and oft flutt’ring Foe! I’ll aulder be gin simmer, sir. So fair, yet won she goes to creeps, so that he answer, Maud has sent its vastness void of Pride, might you term virgo? Later I mean to wanton hair. Love’s bloods might and their treasure suffered all those preserving thus, not ardent Eyes, a Beau and White, doe in Stygian empery.

It is there had spread the name? This Nymph he found and lost landscape green, are painted Bow, or brew fierce that I chaunged in this sun’s noonsted’s made the cleareth. There late it grew proud hear you that awaited my faith proudly sits more love is she mitigates of her hands her on trains my young, I’m all your Chief indeed is ever on the mourn not that sweet rites; the Morning Dream that all her loved not: but still she, chastity hasted are the graves. The walled The Sea of Animal passions, and you triumphal Arches the east of love, if love, which their Loss to live on may foresees its deep, great Anna!

Sighs and opposite two tralucent cisterns brake is statue’s plinth the bloom and forced to sore doth his heart of hem was left the Vision I did part, kiss’d in Lakes on to presage the Box, and keener Light, grave when we soe, as the name and hang in the hungry Judges soon to propane tank, dumb with heart at your wish, though the other that buried are. I am no more joys than the whirling Cross she should leaves fall, trust the sun’s noonsted’s made him was an August night dispairing Spheres and there who long all her Vanities of the Drops to this, ev’n the melting Griefs, and cut they which make death thee more she longer still, to the influence betwixt them, worse, perfect, purple and the melancholy Sprindges we compare the peace, pen, for Sickness, thy summers had Venus, answered, No. If I read in them say more shall feel the course to hang the main tree. When she forswatt I am Adrienne alone.

Know fayre flowers as low. Come, let me knock’d against that Sickeness and Soul and blewe. Her mouth her eyes shut down, chloe steps of Age, trod downe the Chief the sea. Hey ho Bonibell, trust th’ Imperial Form, and base, and Reigns lord of two by harboring world was gives us ourselves not to be moves nor men’s impressed she, whose looked like account Wares, the waves the touch, did she may i stay the heavy do I see a child born, This is my love for the Fire? To Venus’ nun, as he takes the tape-record someday to-morrow’s Seed-field, ere she lets her bosom of the watch all smooth spent I slept.

When, with Bab-o lest griev’d the same floor she streaming out, hey ho gray is a moon is descend. Of such a trance, sir, and the Central Earth, in insomniac … She countenance befall, think us worth all that I want to seek with content the water, and we willing to pay by thy Subjects’ cost, awhile nought I remember, and down upon his song, he dreamed of those with his thou not a man, Dearest, her find you will—but Trusty—knowing Gems unlocks, and final room. He sawe, how broad, sun-spotted out the more ice, and pitie augment my doole thou one. Did not comes for Nisus’ injur’d Hair!

By being punishment and there had spreads around. Or loue I pyne, hey ho the Lamb, and lying in times uncertain this grow, and that’s what a pleasant spring; and all be well. Let its features, they bene thou’t love always redder just where yet so well as basest moulders. And all his Fate and pleasure subjects, but ofttimes in Romances, my manhode brought Slipper knocked as one moment wouldst departed, your graver Prude, or laces, of species are reeking Bag he reply’d there. A Sylph embrace thou’t love he is Syrinx reioyse, that hops about there’s nane again! I fear of iron.

They spring dandelions owne liuely forme in his hands over white Breath, and you speak without a Thomas, or any bitter claim a phantoms rising more clerks, the king the memory is turf, and finds, but be sayde that same flood on a Sconce’s Height to play thee, that weight conceal’d. When kind of granted moan only youths at changes for her but kiss. Beauty fall in drinkin o’t. And she queen of a mother, you may buye golden Crowes this soote, in this unholy battle I grow base: now gynneth things to Venus’ temple fully looked at our place, hermes had won. That shalbe a gracelet rich like far-blown rain, ah, what dewly adayes count Wares, that Jury-men may breede. Of discontent run into the grass, a pure cup of right Desire; my death with the lily marriage, had I been, shall you a degraded with rage possessive and heav’nly Breast renne farre out how thy Neck.

The Peer against than she stings! The Fair each accustomed to be refresht, that drinkin o’t; were will give, so dull a spurn as housewives do strayed, an’ ken ye lyst, ye iolly she, whose Waters lie a World he did reed. Saturn in careless musicks might; those eloquent to here. As she requested, wherefore by one external, to give much honor, when shall see how Meg o’ the smoking it; more tried, to venged for her bosom, is Jenny, fair Loves. Thee calls back my heart with flowers and often strayed, and inspir’d to Lisp, and of my lovers part, of the Earth receives. Will makes you like Braille.

Poor soldiers strife of my woe, bene the tinkling Care. That now the difference. German, I stopped: the beat’s too late! My body now incling lies. Has some parts with snow. But let vs homeward. And wild rose-briar rose tragedy divine in one, to quenched with thee; nor cloudy centuries issued at the Gnomes dire. Thy cup’s heart nectar bowls. With my soule of our life yonder more than the bloom and though neither meant but speed, being fair Head. They both Armies to each one ashamed, which make a look, this second pass, a pure immoral, was fall, trust of alabaster pure; gold ingots like thee.

As Philome thou not heard no more Glory? Or, like there’s nane again! Herrick, this Lock, of wandring door-bells upon his Beams lanch’d on the green. Up like a song are, when thy train Leander, be it to her fair Love, nor want our bodies lose name? The Nymph opprest, of two, or pity you apt to keep the beads I kiss thereto; Honour forbidden Blushes, books shall beauty dispairing along his life of her nest, and maine, when I prais’d, which would be gone. At first, and afterward daybreak. For whom all shou’d feele: but who reward she wept her on her eyes are circuses, so I am.

100

But all around restore than can the Song. And that she that seeing eyes! Enjoy each importance soon it will mought ne gang war wrapped&cut diagonal at the bush he died to scanne: he plonged Diana, in her righted Hair dissever from all to sette thee. How would pick through the hair. Gentle will, your heart in twain, the old sharp’st in the bold Homer’s honey’d rain still wrapped in the People’s purse—the Sex to a trembling, kiss the vaunted verse of lawn, the way your Locks in Peace, fell silent Dead the break a twofold the Return their grant himself more a grave. But beauty cannot quenche thye thirstye payne.

101

A rose-bud, young Apollo’s gold complained to Cupids dart an imagined you here they took such a season, in ev’ry Atome just like a globe may her alone, wherewith still sleep. How each other’s steeds, when twas the close between her lot to beauty had heart made reply’d the judgement, this instigated there are two captive Queene. What diff’ring Fiends, the Nurse and title to their former colour, Ah, yes! Whom you of mortal Pride; and trembled. Yet shall be refresht, thought it mountains, and three, I would I climber for hir darling eddies, and helmes vnbruzed wexen wider. Fate urg’d the difference.

#poetry #automatically generated text #Patrick Mooney #Markov chains #Markov chain length: 6 #160 texts #sonnet sequence

0 notes